Report this comment
  • "Yet another example of private for-profit organisations failing when they take over public sector functions. How long will we put up with the myth that private companies are better run than the public sector?

    We have school dinners, private nursing homes, private care homes, rail, airports, etc, etc, etc. All have been involved in scandals and cost cutting to the point of putting people at risk."
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.


  • Enter the above word in the box below

Inquiries launched to find if doctor was drunk on duty following death of Dorothy "Betty" Seecoomar

Wandsworth Guardian: Inquiries launched to find if doctor was drunk on duty following death of Dorothy "Betty" Seecoomar Inquiries launched to find if doctor was drunk on duty following death of Dorothy "Betty" Seecoomar

Health watchdogs and an NHS trust have launched investigations into the death of a frail pensioner just hours after an out-of-hours doctor was allegedly "too drunk" to operate her oxygen supply.

Agnes Seecoomar claims the doctor, who has not been named, arrived at her mother Dorothy's flat, in Dover House Road, Putney, "incoherent and slurring his words" on August 15 this year.

She alleged he turned up with bloodshot eyes, appeared to be under the influence of alcohol or drugs and failed to understand a St George's Hospital registrar's simple instructions during a subsequent phone conversation.

Her mother had been recovering at home from a serious chest infection and was on an oxygen supply when she called for an out-of-hours doctor.

The 81-year-old was admitted to hospital the next day but died just 24 hours later on August 17 prompting both her daughter and the registrar to launch a complaint.

Harmoni, the largest private provider of urgent care services in England, employed the doctor and spent two months investigating the incident.

The company dismissed the doctor last week but found no indication of alcohol or drug abuse.

Ms Seecoomar, a teacher from West London, said her mother had suffered unnecessary distress.

She said: "Any competent doctor would have seen she was not getting enough oxygen.

"I told the registrar I was frightened as the doctor attending my mother appeared incapable of doing his job, was rambling, sweating profusely now and his eyes were bloodshot.

"The registrar told me he would report him straight away.

"People think we still have an NHS - but we don't, we have commissioners and providers.

"It seems to be a competition to see who can provide healthcare at the lowest possible cost."

NHS South West London, who contracted Harmoni for out-of-hours care, and the General Medical Council, the body which licenses doctors, have both opened inquiries.

The Care Quality Commission, the healthcare watchdog, is also examining the case.

A spokesperson for Harmoni said: "We have contacted Ms Seecoomar and did invite her to meet with us.

"Ms Seecoomar declined this invitation so we have sent her our findings in writing which include confirmation that the doctor no longer works for Harmoni.

"There is no evidence at all to support any suggestion or allegation that this doctor was intoxicated whilst on duty."

Local Businesses

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree